Creativity is messy...but don’t boo.
Friday, September 28, 2012 at 10:51AM |
Travis Sheridan Note: Gina and I attended together, but I am not attempting to speak for her; therefore, I will use “I” instead of “we” in this post.
Last night Pecha Kucha Night, St. Louis occurred as part of St. Louis DesignWeek. The week was packed with cool events and I tried to attend as many as possible. Being a raving PK fan, I imagined Thursday was going to be a perfect storm - Design, PK, and Plush.
The vibe was strange and I left at the beer break; therefore, this is only based on my first half experience.
I am not one to cast blame or offer criticism w/o being constructive. I’ll also add this fact: I have attend about 20 Pecha Kucha Nights, in five different cities, and in various roles (host, presenter, audience member, setter-upper, and presenting someone else’s slides when they failed to show). I’ve attended three events in STL, but last night something was amiss.
Presentations: Like most PKNs, not all were polished or perfect. I like that about PK and give people props for sharing pieces of themselves with us. I learn something each PKN I attend. Maybe not from each presenter, but I do learn something.
Don’t fucking boo a presenter. What does that actually accomplish? Seriously, let’s work this out together. A presenter has put together 20 slides and 6:40 of content. Public speaking is not easy for anyone (shouting “BOO” in total darkness is damn easy, ya little dick). Do you think booing suddenly triggers a better presentation? Like an already nervous and vulnerable person will hear you and immediately abandon the safety net of their prepared remarks to make a modification that will appease you? Fuck NO! All you did was prove that you are a total tool. Yay!
Think of PKN like sex with several partners. Each encounter lasts 6:40 (some of you just set personal records, btw) and some will leave you wanting more from that person while others just leave you wanting. Okay, you weren’t satisfied. But quit being selfish. Chalk it up to virgin jitters and move on to the next one. Criticizing a partner during sex never resulted in a better orgasm...unless you are into that kind of thing.
Host/Emcee: I might make enemies here, but it’s not about the host. Consider the meaning of the term Pecha Kucha...chit chat or conversation. The emcee’s sole purpose is to maintain the fluid nature of the conversation. When talking with friends, many of us use paraphrasing to check in and show that we get it. A host can do this for the crowd. Facilitate the understanding between presenter and audience. I’d like to see the emcee make a simple connection to the presenter who just finished and transition to the next one. Set up the audience and let the presenter shine. Last night, it seemed like the time between presenters was filled with non sequitur content that proved the emcee was smart. I have no doubt that he is and would probably enjoy a PK presentation from him.
The host also needs to manage the crowd in a way that is firm and respectful. Here’s what I wrote for last night’s booing situation...set-up, the presenter was the creative director from Dr. Scholl’s and had a cool presentation. A guy boos in the middle of it and things spiral for the presenter.
Host: “Let’s give _______ a round of applause. This is never easy, but we are a community and he is part of this community. If his presentation taught us anything, it showed us that there is a lot of “sole” in shoe design...and what the gentleman in the crowd proved is that you can’t talk shoes without at least one heel.”
Maybe it isn’t perfectly funny, but the point is that the issue can be addressed and a connection can be made back to the presentation...bring it back to the presenter.
It’s not always like this, it just was last night. I attribute it to the overall vibe. I am not attacking a person. Something was just odd.
Venue: Plush is great. Gina and I eat there often and it has become our Sunday brunch place. I don’t know if they were ready for the crowd. The bartender (on the restaurant side) was feeling under the weather and grumpy. I actually said to him, “Hey, don’t yell at me.” It would have been nice to open the bar upstairs and spread the love a little. The venue also had several obstructed views. I get that. Hey, arrive early to get a good seat. But PKNSTL draws huge crowds and the choice of venue needs to be able to accommodate the crowd.
I sent some tweets and talked Gina’s ear off ranting about my frustration. But as the opening line of this post says, “creativity is messy.” I will always support, promote and attend Pecha Kucha (here and in other cities) because it is a great opportunity to showcase the beauty that can come from the mess.
To the guy who booed, seriously...NOT COOL.


